New fossils of small and medium-sized bovids from the Early Site of Shanshenmiaozui in Nihewan Basin, North China
2022, 60 (2
Shanshenmiaozui site in Nihewan Basin in North China is a recently discovered Early Pleistocene site which yields rich and diverse mammalian fossils. In the fauna, the small and medium-sized bovid fossils are well represented and can be referred to the following taxa: Spirocerus wongi, Gazella sinensis, Ovis shantungensis and Megalovis piveteaui respectively, among which G. sinensis is the dominate species. S. wongi and G. sinensis are mainly represented by horn-cores and partial skull bones as well as mandibles; in addition, metacarpal and/or metatarsal bones were also recognized for all of the four species. The horn-cores are easy to be identified to the species level, while the dentitions and the postcranial bones underwent a series of examinations and comparisons before getting properly determined and referred to the most approximate taxa. Among the postcranial bones, the metapodials, especially to the metacarpal bones special attentions were paid, which are crucial not only for taxonomic identification, but also for phylogenetic and paleoecological reconstructions; the previously misidentified metapodial specimens in Nihewan fauna were reconsidered in this paper. In the SSMZ fauna, the bovid guild is dominated by Gazella and Bison, which indicates steppe was the most important biome in Nihewan Basin during Early Pleistocene.
|Species ||S. wongi ||S. wongi ||S. wongi ||S. peii ||S. kiakhtensis ||S. kiakhtensis ||Ovis shantungensis|
|Sources ||This paper ||Teilhard & Piveteau (1930) ||Bai et al. (2019) ||Young (1932) ||Boule et al. (1928) ||Dong et al. (2009) ||This paper|
|DP2 ||L ||14.2-14.5 ||13 || || || ||10.5 ||9.5|
| ||W ||10-10.2 ||8 || || || ||7.7 ||7.4|
|DP3 ||L ||19.9-20.3 ||19-23 || || || ||12.5 ||14.8|
| ||W ||13.6-14.2 ||10-12 || || || ||11.1 ||12.8|
|DP4 ||L ||23.5-23.7 ||22-24 || || || ||16.5 ||18.0-18.5|
| ||W ||16.8-18.1 ||12 || || || ||13.6 ||15.1-15.5|
|DP2-4 ||L ||56.2-57.4 ||52 || || || ||39.4 ||41.9|
|M1 ||L ||26.6-26.7 ||19? || || || ||19.5-24.9 ||24.0-24.3|
| ||W ||15.3 ||15? || || || ||18.2-23.9? ||15.7-15.8|
|dp2 ||L ||10.5-10.8 || || || || || |
| ||W ||6.6-6.7 || || || || || |
|dp3 ||L ||16.4-16.6 || || || || || |
| ||W ||9.2 || || || || || |
|dp4 ||L ||28.2-28.5 || || || || || |
| ||W ||11.3-11.6 || || || || || |
|p4 ||L ||13.6 ||13-15 ||17.1 ||12 ||15 || |
| ||W ||8.4 ||9 ||8.3 ||9 ||9 || |
|m1 ||L ||17.9 ||13-20 ||17.2 ||15 ||25? || |
| ||W ||12.3 ||11-14 ||10.7 ||11 ||11 || |
|m2 ||L ||23.2 ||21-26 ||21.6 ||21 ||26 || |
| ||W ||12.6 ||12-13 ||10.7 ||11.5 ||13 || |
|m3 ||L ||32.2 ||32 ||30.2 ||32 || || |
| ||W ||11.7 ||11-13 ||10.1 ||12 || || |
Measurements of the teeth of Spirocerus wongi, compared with related species (mm)
Extracts from the Article
Deciduous upper teeth (Fig. 2B3;
Table 3): All of the deciduous upper cheek teeth are completely molarized except DP2. DP2 is elongated, but the posterior lobe is relatively reduced and the posterior fossette (or infundibulum) is shallow. The DP3 has much more wider but shorter posterior lobe relative to the anterior one, and the two fossettes are V-shaped in occlusal view; the mesostyle rib is quite pronounced, the lingual wall of the first lobe is roundish. The DP4 has a much more wider anterior lobe relative to the posterior one; the mesostyle rib is also quite pronounced; the lingual wall of the posterior lobe is more roundish relative to the anterior one. The metacone rib is less developed in all three kinds of tooth. The dimensions of the deciduous teeth are shown in
Permanent lower teeth (Fig. 2D1-4;
Table 3): Only one partial mandible preserves p4 to m3. The p4 is very advanced in well developed protoconid and metaconid, but other cuspids are extremely reduced; metaconid is column-like but connects with paraconid mesially by a narrow bridge, it doesn’t contact protoconid; there is a narrow and deep groove between metaconid and entoconid. The m1 and m2 are very similar in morphology, except the latter is longer and has more developed goat fold; the infundibulums are very narrow; the lingual cuspids are compressed linguobuccally and the lingual wall is quite flat. The m3 has three lobes, the front two of which are very similar to m2 in shape and size; the third lobe has no infundibulums and is linguobuccally compressed. From the lingual aspect, prominent parastylid and entostylid ribs on m2 and m3 can be seen, and even a rib at the linguo-distal corner of hypoconulid lobe can also be observed, but the mesostylid rib is only slightly developed at the top part of the crown. From the buccal view, no basal pillars can be observed.
Maxilla: One maxilla with left DP4-M1 and right DP2-M1 (IVPP V 28693) (Fig. 2E1-2) can be referred to
Ovis shantungensis. The DP2 is deeply worn and the infundibulum has disappeared. The DP3 is moderately worn, with robust paracone and metacone as well as metaconule, the protocone is less developed, with robust parastyle, the posterior lobe is wider than the anterior one. The DP4 has equally developed main cusps, and the styles are also equally developed; the paracone rib is very robust, the anterior lobe is wider than the posterior one. In form, the M1 is very similar with DP4, but much bigger and more hypsodont. The dimensions of the teeth are shown in
Other Images/Table from this Article
Location of Shanshenmiaozui (SSMZ) site, with distributional map of living antelopes and related fossil forms of the Pleistocene Epoch in China Data for the extant taxa are from Jiang (
), Smith and Xie (
). Fossil localities: 1. Xiashagou of Nihewan; 2. Yushe; 3. Dongdoubi of Yuxian; 4. Jinyuan Cave; 5. Zhoukoudian Loc.1;6. Xujiayao; 7. Mashandong; 8. Salawusu; 9. Xifeng of Qingyang; 10. Loufangzi; 11. Jinniushan;12. Miaohoushan; 13. Haimao of Dalian; 14. Gulongshan; 15. Xiaogushan; 16. Chicheng; 17. Dingcun;18. Xihoudu; 19. Tianshuigou of Dali; 20. Wenxi; 21. Pinglu; 22. Danangou of Yuxian; 23. Bajiazui;24. Gonghe; 25. Yangguo; 26. Tuozidong; 27. Tunliu; 28. Banpo; 29. Linyi; 30. Yuanmou; 31. Heshui;32. Xingtai; 33. Xiaochangcun; 34. Wuwang of Linyi; 35. Gengjiagou; 36. Luhuo; 37. Zhoukoudian Loc.15;38. Upper Cave; 39. Guxiangtun; 40. Zhoujiayoufang; 41. Dali Man site; 42. Aba; 43. Chifeng;44. Rouyuan; 45. Yanjiagang; 46. Yuhongcun of Dali; 47. Lingjing
Studied fossil specimens of small to medium-sized bovids newly unearthed from SSMZ
Partial skulls, jaw bones and teeth of Spirocerus wongi (A-D) and Ovis shantungensis (E) from SSMZ A-D.
Spirocerus wongi: A. partial skull with horn-cores (IVPP V 28650), B1-B3. juvenile maxilla with DP2-M1 (V 28651), C1-C4. left mandible with dp2-m1 (V 28652.1), D1-D4. partial right mandible with p4-m3 (V 28653); E1-E2.
Ovis shantungensis, maxilla with left DP4-M1 and right DP2-4 and M1 (V 28693) A. anterior view; B1, E1. palatal views; B2, C1, D1, E2. buccal views; C2, D2. lingual views;B3, C3-4, D3-4. occlusal views. The unmarked scale bars equal 20 mm
CT scan images and 3-D reconstructions of the horn-core of Spirocerus wongi from SSMZ (IVPP V 28650) A1-A2. CT scan images showing the general canal system (A1) and a longitudinal slice (A2);C1-C5. CT scan slices showing the changes of cross sections and the canal system at different levels;B1-B4. CT image reconstruction of the right horn-core in anterior (B1), lateral (B2), posterior (B3) and medial (B4) views
Measurements of the horn-cores of Spirocerus wongi, compared with related species (mm)
Postcranial bones of small and medium-sized bovids from SSMZ A-C.
Spirocerus wongi: A1-A3. left Mc III+IV (IVPP V 28655),B1-B4. right naviculo-cuboid+lat-mid+medial cuneiforms (V 28656.2-3),C1-C3. right Mt III+IV (V 28656.4); D-I.
Gazella sinensis: D1-D3. partial left humerus (V 28687),E1-E4. left Mc III+IV (V 28688), F. distal epiphysis of left tibia (V 28691),G1-G2. left astragalus (V 28692), H1-H2. left naviculo-cuboid (V 28690), I1-I3. 3rd phalanx (V 28689);J-K.
Megalovis piveteaui: J1-J4. left radius (V 28654), K1-K4. right Mc III+IV (V 28695);L1-L4.
Ovis shantungensis: left Mc III+IV (V 28694). A1, C1, D1, E1, G1, J1, K1, L1. anterior views;A2, B4, C2, D2, E2, G2, J2, K2, L2. posterior views; A3, B1, C3, E3, H1, J3, K3, L3. proximal views;B2, D3, E4, F, H2, J4, K4, L4. distal views; B3. medial view; I1. lateral view; I2. interdigital view;I3. volar view. The arrows indicate the lateral projection of the radius. The unmarked scale bars equal 20 mm
Measurements of metacarpals of bovids from Nihewan Basin, compared with related taxa (mm)
Incomplete skulls and horn-cores of Gazella sinensis from SSMZ A. partial skull of a juvenile with horn-cores (IVPP V 28658); B1-B3. partial skull with horn-cores (V 28657); C1-C2. left and right horn-cores (V 28659.1, V 28659.2); D1-D2. partial skull with left horn-core (V 28667);E. partial skull with right horn-core (V 28661). A, B1, C1-2, D1. anterior views; B3. posterior view;B2. dorsal view; E. medial view; D2. lateral view. Scale bars equal 50 mm
Measurements of partial cranial bones and horn-cores of Gazella sinensis (mm)
CT scan images of the horn-core of Gazella sinensis (IVPP V 28661) from SSMZ A1-A4. CT image reconstruction showing positions of the cross CT scan slices (A1’-A4’);B1-B3. CT image reconstruction showing positions of the longitudinal CT scan slices (B1’-B3’)
Jaw bones and teeth of Gazella sinensis from SSMZ (A-J), compared with related taxa (K-P) A. maxilla with P3-M1 (IVPP V 28673); B. maxilla with M1-3 (V 28674);C1-C4. left mandible with p2-m3 (V 28680); D1-D3. left mandible with p2-m3 (V 28681.2);E1-E2. left mandible with dp2-4 and m1-2 (V 28685.1), E3. detail of dp2-4; F. right p4-m3 (V 28677);G. left p3-m3 (V 28682); H. right p2-m3 (V 28675); I. left p4-m3 (V 28686); J. left p4-m3 (V 28678);K.
Procapra przewalskii, right p2-m3 (horizontally flipped) (NWIPB-0001172♀);L.
Procapra gutturosa, left p2-m3 (NWIPB 620032); M.
Gazella subgutturosa, left p2-m3 (NWIPB 609001);N.
Pseudois nahaur, left p2-m3 (NWIPB-KX1); O.
Capra ibex, left p2-m3 (IOZ-2);P.
Ovis ammon, left p2-m3 (OV 1346-2). A, B, C1, C4, D1, E3, F-P. occlusal views;C2, D2, E1. buccal views; C3, D3, E2. lingual views. The arrows indicate the variations of p4 The unmarked scale bars equal 20 mm
Measurements of teeth of Gazella sinensis from SSMZ, compared with those from Xiashagou (mm)
Comparison of premolar series among some Quaternary gazelle species of China A.
Gazella sinensis, left p2-4, IVPP V 28681.2, SSMZ; B.
Procapra gutturosa, left p2-4, NWIPB 0006065, extant; C.
P. przewalskii, right p2-4 (horizontally flipped), NWIPB 0001172, extant;D.
P. picticaudata, left p2-4, NWIPB 0001179, extant; E.
Gazella subgutturosa, left p2-4, IVPP-c-05, extant;F.
Saiga tatarica, right p3-4 (horizontally flipped), NWIPB S-80503, extant;G.
Pantholops hodgsonii, left p3-4, NWIPB 77001, extant. All are in occlusal views
Toothrow length and cranial size of extant gazelles in China Raw data was employed from Jiang,
Maxilla of Megalovis piveteaui (MNHN-NIH 150) from Xiashagou of Nihewan A. buccal view; B. occlusal view
Length vs distal width of metacarpal bones of diverse bovids The data un-included in
are from Colbert and Hooijer,